Visual Perceptual Memory
Group Project #1
Psychobiology 325
March 9, 2001
Debra Pizzuto
Michael Fry
Shaw Gillespie
Introduction
The following pieces explore the phenomenon of long term visual
perceptual memory, touching on cerebral relationships, synaptic changes,
and physiological differences in the visually impaired. The first piece
covers cerebral pathways relating to visual perceptual memory and
learning, and functions of these pathways. The second portion explores
the locations and mechanisms of synaptic change that facilitate visual
associative memory. The final portion deals with the genetic
characteristics of a rare visual disorder at the photoreceptor level of
the retina.
Cerebral Relationships of Visual Perceptual Learning and Memory
by: Debra Pizzuto
The act of conscious perception of a sensory impression and the
content of perception with meaning and association are two factors of
perception. Learning involves recognition. Study of learning involves
how to recognize stimuli, changes and variations of the familiar.
Physiologically, visual perception involves changes in the structure of
neuronal synapses resulting
from past experience in the visual environment. Donald Hebb
hypothesized in 1949, if a synapse is repeatedly active when a
postsynaptic neuron fires, changes take place in the structure that
will change it. This change is the proposed mechanism of long term
potentiation (LTP) phenomenon involved in strengthening of synaptic
connections within memory networks. (LTP) is the enduring increase of
synaptic efficiency following the repeated activation of presynaptic
fibers. This form of postsynaptic excitatory facilitation was
discovered in synaptic elements of granular cell dendrites in the
dendrite gyrus which receive inputs from the entorinal cortex via
perforant path (Will,140). The process seems at least theoretically to
physically change the structure of neural systems in the brain when
learning occurs.
Phenominalogy mechanisms extensively reviewed by Swanson et
al(1982), Voronin (1983), and Eccles (1983) in Buser's Cerebral
Correlates of Conscious Experience, distinguishes three elements of
LTP: long duration, lasting enhancement of synaptic efficiency produced
by short high frequency stimulus that mimic bursts of activity
occurring in hippocampal neurons spontaineously. LTP also requires a
number of coactive convergent synapses to be set into an active state.
There is much evidence that synapse remodeling occurs as a result of
specific learning experiences in adults, early visual cues and one
trial avoidance learning.
Additionally, studies based on experimental evidence from
depriving in neonates or exposure to enriched environment in early life
and adulthood (Rosenzweig & Bennet, 1976) propose that relatively
permanent fixation of acquired information is the result of a long
lasting change in some synaptic parameter with resulting formation of
neural pathways. Behavioral studies
compare with numerous studies finding patients with inferotemporal
cortex lesions made numerous errors during initial learning of visual
discriminations, as well as recall of previously learned discrimination
(Merigan & Maunsell, 1993).
Persistent synaptic modifications in neural networks seem to be the
basis for information storage. Therefore, memories are
multidimensional. Synaptic reorganization occurs in multiple relays in
relevant networks throughout the brain.
Without excitation from relevant stimuli (inactive memory), the
network defined by the activity pattern along the connective structure,
is potentially maintained by permanent connection points within the
network (Bloch& Laroche, 1984). Bloch and Laroche examined the
development of LTP in learning proposing that the change is assumed to
occur during the phase of information processing, generated by
perseverative activation triggered in neural networks by incoming
information.
Perseverative processes may play a role in storage and retrieval
of information as their studies further indicate. In these studies, MRF
stimulation was delivered 10 seconds after each high frequency train to
perforant path fibers. Experimental findings parallel the behavioral
data in classical conditioning. Behavioral studies provide strong
evidence that a low intensity post trial MRF stimulation facilitates
learning in a variety of experimental situations, including active
avoidance (Bloch et al, 1970), extinction of bar pressing or maze
learning (Deweer,1976).
Two limbic circuits mediate neural pathways, with sensory input
from the frontal cortex in the hippocampal system. According to
Kornhuber's theory, hippocampal formation response to sensory stimulus
seems to have predictive value rather than a specific behavior
response. First the Papez loop: hippocampus, subiculim, mammillary
body, anterior thalamic nucleus, cingulate gyrus, and hippocampus. The
other circuit leads from the association cortices to the hippocampus
via the cingulate gyrus and the mediodorsal thalamus to the prefrontal
lobe (Buser, 1978). The inputs from the frontal, to the (sensory)
temporal and parietal association areas send to the hippocampus via the
cingulate gyrus. These areas identify memory and establish new circuits
in learning. Lesions to the temporal cortex cause difficulty with form
discrimination (agnosia). The output from the hippocamus (primordial
cells) is via the mediodorsal thalamus to the frontal lobe. This area
is involved with the perception of objects location in space (Buser,
1978).
Most complicated processes of molecular biology are involved in
visual perception. Researchers find difficulty drawing theoretical
conclusions from data examined. Damage to the visual system at any
level can effect profoundly the adequacy of perception and the
efficiency of its accomplishment. When higher parts of the visual
system are destroyed, the production of visual consciousness ceases to
operate. Researchers indicate that cerebral relationships of neural
networks consisting in multilevel divisions seem to contribute to
visual perceptions leading to learning and LTM.
References:
Buser, P. & Rougeul Buser, A. (1978). Cerebral Correlates of Conscious
Experience. Netherlands: Elsevier/North Holland Biomedical Press
Carlson, N. R. (2001). Physiology of Behavior. Needham Heights MA:
Allyn and Bacon
Dimond, S. J. (1980). Neuropsychology. Boston, MA: Butterworth
Publishersinc.
Tsukada, Y. & Agranoff, B. (1984). Neurobiological Basis of Learning
and Memory. New York: John Wiley & Sons
Will, B.E (1984). Brain Plasticity, Learning, and Memory. New York:
Plenum Press
Synaptic Mechanisms of Long Term Visual Perceptual Memory
by Shaw Gillespie
It is currently common consensus among researchers that perceptual
learning (recognition of a particular stimulus or categories of
stimuli) is generally the domain of regions of the appropriate sensory
association cortex (Carlson, 1997). Here we will narrow the scope,
looking only at visual perceptual memory and evidence revealing the
locations and mechanisms that make visual perception and recollection
possible.
Locations
While visual short term memory seems to involve areas of the
prefrontal cortex (Quintana and Fuster, 1999; Blumhardt, 1999),
evidence supports the idea that cells in the temporal / temporal
occipital region are highly specialized, responding to an aggregate of
color, form, texture, and shape data from the extrastriate cortex. Long
term visual perceptual memory involves changes at the synaptic level in
these cells in the inferior temporal cortex (Tanaka, 1993). However,
Biederman et. al. (1995) has found evidence that indicates that the
anterior region of the inferior temporal cortex may not be involved in
perceptual memory or recall.
Likely, the synaptic changes in the inferior temporal region
responsible for visual perception of complex stimuli involve the
strengthening of various synapses through a process such as long term
potentiation (LTP). There is evidence to implicate NMDA receptors as
contributing to LTP in the mammalian visual cortex (Seki, Kudoh &
Shibuki, 1999). Additionally, Niu et. al. (1999) found that the
presence of NMDA antagonists inhibited synaptic strengthening by long
term potentiation in rat hippocampi. Given all this, it seems likely
that LTP plays some role in the formation of new neural circuits in the
visual cortex, and it is possible that LTP contributes to the synaptic
changes responsible for perception of complex visual stimuli by cells
in the inferior temporal cortex.
Mechanisms
The increase in synaptic strength due to LTP may be the result of
several different types of changes in the postsynaptic, presynaptic, or
both pre and postsynaptic cells. There is evidence to support all of
these possibilities. Additionally, there is evidence that links changes
in presynaptic neurons to the initial postsynaptic changes that occur
due to the influx of calcium though NMDA controlled ion channels.
Postsynaptic changes include increased number of postsynaptic
receptors, increased communication between the postsynaptic spine and
the rest of the cell, and increased ability of postsynaptic receptors
to affect cell membrane permeability. Presynaptic changes that
strengthen the synapse involve an increased release of
neurotransmitter. Synaptic changes that involve both the pre and
postsynaptic neurons include the formation of new synapses.
Evidence pointing to postsynaptic change contributing to the
synaptic strengthening seen during LTP has been accumulating rapidly.
NMDA mediated LTP has been shown to increase the number of AMPA
receptors(Liao, Hessler, and Malinow, 1995), which strengthen the
synapse by virtue of being able to more effectively produce excitatory
postsynaptic potentials, and to decrease the number of NMDA receptor
sites(Segal & Andersen, 2000). These changes take place through action
of...
Increased communication between synapses has been seen to occur
through the action of what are termed perforated synapses, and Buchs
and Muller (1996) have observed that LTP has lead to the formation of
perforated synapses in targeted dendritic spines. Perforated synapse
formation can involve both small and large scale shape changes. These
changes involve bringing more of the spine's membrane surface closer to
the presynaptic bouton, so that it can form a larger active site or a
greater number of active sites that facilitate the triggering of
postsynaptic potentials. Small scale shape changes to the spine can
take place without the addition or removal of new membrane material due
to the membrane fluidity (Segal and Andersen, 2000). However, large
scale changes require the addition of new membrane material through the
action of lipid vesicles and protein synthesis. The conversion of ATP
to cyclic AMP (triggered by calcium influx) within the postsynaptic
spine triggers the phosphorylation of various proteins within the cell.
Sanchez et. al. (1999) found evidence linking the phosphorylation of
the microtubule associated protein 2 family of proteins to large
changes in cell structure and plasticity.
Another type of change involving the postsynaptic neuron involves
increased communication between the dendritic spine and the rest of the
postsynaptic neuron. Following long term potentiation, the neck of an
affected dendritic spine becomes thicker to facilitate better
intracellular chemical communication with the rest of the cell. These
structural changes are thought to be accomplished through
phosphorylizing action of type calcium calmodulin kinase on various
MAP2 type proteins that can carry new membrane material to the spine
from the rest of the neuron(Sanchez et. al., 1999).
Changes in presynaptic neuron such as the spouting of new terminal
boutons are thought to be the result of signaling by the postsynaptic
cell by way of nitric oxide (Carlson, 1997). Production of nitric oxide
is mediated by nitric oxide synthase activated by events resulting from
the entry of calcium into cell during LTP. Nitric oxide gas is highly
soluble and can diffuse across a wide area in a relatively short time,
providing a convenient messenger to the presynaptic cell. In the
presynaptic cell, there is evidence to suggest that nitric oxide
triggers a heightened amount of cyclic GMP which, in turn, leads to a
heightened amount of neurotransmitter released when the presynaptic
bouton fires (Haley, Wilcox and Chapman, 1992; Mize and Lo, 2000).
Overall, it seems that the process of LTP does not involve a
single change, but rather a series of changes, or chain reaction, that
leads to alteration of both the pre and postsynaptic cell.
Theoretically, these changes refine associative neural pathways in the
inferior temporal cortex that contribute to the perception and
recognition of visual stimuli.
References:
Blumhardt, L. Characterising brain activity associated with short term
memory processes. Electroencephalography and Clinical Neurophysiology,
1997, 103, 48.
Biederman, I., Gerhardstein, P., Cooper, E., and Nelson, C. High level
object recognition without an inferior temporal lobe. Neuropsychologia,
1995, 3, 271 to 281.
Buchs, P., and Muller, D. Induction of long term potentiation is
associated with major ultrastructural changes of activated synapses.
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA, 1996, 93, 8040 to
8045.
Carlson, N. Physiology of Behavior. Massachusetts: Allyn and Bacon,
1998.
Haley, J., Wilcox, G., and Chapman, P. The role of nitric oxide in
hippocampal long term potentiation. Neuron, 1992, 8, 211 to 216.
Liao, D., Hessler, N., and Malinow, R. Activation of postsynaptically
silent synapses during pairing induced LTP in CA1 region of hippocampal
slice. Nature, 1995, 375, 400 to 404.
Mize, R., and Lo, F. Nitric oxide, impulse activity, and neurotrophins
in visual system development. Brain Research, 2000, 886, 15 to 32.
Niu, Y., Xiao, M., Karpefors, M., Wigstrom, H. Potentiation and
depression following stimulus interruption in young rat hippocampi.
NeuroReport, 1999, 10, 919 to 923.
Segal, M., and Andersen, P. Dendritic spines shaped by synaptic
activity. Current Opinion in Neurobiology, 2000, 10, 582 to 586.
Sanchez, C., Diaz Nido, J., Avila, J. Phosphorylation of microtubule
associated protein 2 and its relevance for the regulation of the
neuronal cytoskeleton function. Progress in Neurobiology, 2000, 61, 133
to 168.
Seki, K., Kudoh, M., and Shibuki, K. Long term potentiation of calcium
signal in the rat auditory cortex. Neuroscience Research, 1999, 34, 187
to 197.
Tanaka, K. Neuronal mechanisms of object recognition. Science, 1993,
262, 685 to 688.
Quintana, J., Fuster, J. From perception to action: Temporal
integrative functinos of prefrontal and parietal neurons. Cerebral
Cortex, 1999, 9, 213 to 221.
The Genetic Characteristics of Blue Cone Monochromacy
By Mike Fry
Imagine a world void of color, a world without the richness of
reds or the vibrancy of yellows. Such an existence is a reality for a
small fraction of the overall population. This begs the question as to
where these people lead less fulfilling lives than those who can
experience the kaleidoscope of hues that paint the imagination.
Perhaps, one could argue, there are experiences that will never be had
but overall achromats, those individuals who have no cone cell
photoreceptors, and monochromats, those people with only one set of
functional cone cell photoreceptors, have proven to live fruitful,
happy lives. There is some speculation as to whether monochromats can
decipher color with one set of cones and a full complement of rods
cells. Empirical test have illustrated that yellow can easily be
identified on a blue background and vice versa. Blue Cone Monochromats
(BCM) have reported that they do actually experience color, though may
be a perceptual illusion. Some people with BCM have reported being
able to distinguish among the seven colors of the rainbow and are able
to pass simple color test
Background
In the back of the eye is a thin sheet of film like material that
is directly connected to the brain via the optic verve called the
retina. The retina consists of seven layers of specific cells that are
responsible for relaying information gathered from the photoreceptors
along the appropriate path to the various areas of the brain. Perhaps
due to an evolutionary fluke or possible because of the extreme
sensitivity of these highly specialized cells, photoreceptor cells
constitute the inner most layer of the retina. There are two distinct
types of photoreceptors called cones and rods. Photoreceptors primary
function is to gather and start the initial processing of light that
enters through the pupil.
On a cellular level, rods have a large receptive field and lower
convergence to magno ganglion cells. They are located more densely at
the peripheral regions of the retina becoming sparse towards the
macular region (center portion of the retina). Rod cells are highly
sensitive to light and movement but lack the ability to discriminate
fine detail or color. They are largely responsible for scotopic, or
night vision, and as such they are specialized at gathering information
about movement, size, and shape of objects, however they have poor
resolution, an as such cannot distinguish color or detail.
Conversely, cones are densely packed in the macular region
becoming less dense in the peripheral areas. They have a much smaller
receptive field and significantly higher convergence to parvo ganglion
cells. It takes considerably more stimulation to cause a cone to
increase its random firing. They are wavelength sensitive and have the
ability to distinguished fine details. There are three types of cone
cells in the retina, each defined by the color of pigment it contains
corresponding to the wave length frequency they are most sensitive too.
Cones are commonly categorized as blue (or short wavelength), green (or
medium wave length), or red (long wave length). It is the mixing and
matching of the input from the combinations of these cells that allows
for normal color vision. In BCM cone cells develop normally, but due
to a genetic defect the body is unable to produce the red and green
Opsin proteins necessary to fill the cone cells with their appropriate
pigment. Thus people with BCM have a complete complement of rod cells
and theoretically the appropriate amount of cone cells, but due to a
genetic defect they only have an effective class of short wave length
cones.
Blue Cone Monochromacy
Studies have concluded that there are very few if any blue cones
located in the fovea, a cone rich portion of the retina directly behind
the pupil, which is responsible for central vision. Consequently those
people affected by BCM exhibit symptoms of poor central visual acuity,
ranging from 20/50 to 20/300, poor color discrimination, early onset of
nystagmus (shaky eyes), varying degrees of myopia (near sightedness)
and hypermetropia far sightedness), and photophobia (aversion to bright
light). People with BCM have almost normal retinal appearance. Given
that fact coupled with the rarity of occurrence makes dig gnosis a
difficult process. Often time's people who do have BCM will be wrongly
diagnosed as hav9ing some other type of retinal disorders, such as
Retina Pigmatosea. A color test measuring wavelength sensitivity while
controlling for light intensity is the most effective means of
diagnosing BCM. In occasional cases of BCM people will report
progressive deterioration of central vision.
BCM is an extremely rare X-linked recessive retinal disorder,
occurring in the United States population in an estimated onep3erson
out of every hundred thousand. Genes on the X chromosome provide the
instructions, which manufacture the proteins necessary for the
production of the red and green Opsin. Research has implicated linkage
of BCM to 2 DNA markers (DXS15 and DXS52) that map in the Xq28 (on the
lower arm of the X chromosome) region.
Females usually never display phenotypic symptoms of BCM. The X
chromosome is involved with determining a child's gender. Normal males
have a genotype of (X, Y) and normal females have a genotype of (X, X).
A person who has BCM has a defect on a single X chromosome that
prevents the formation of red and green pigment for cone cells. A
female who carries an effectived X chromosomes also always dose not
show symptoms of BCM, because she also has a normal X chromosome that
"protects" her form the defect. X I-inactivation, which is the random
inactivation of either maternal X or a paternal X chromosome during the
32 cell stage of pre-embryonic development usually ensures that a
suitable amount of normal X chromosome will be activated to allow her
to have a fairly normal collection of red and green cone cells. These
normal red and green cone cells accompanied with her blue cone cells
should allow her to have close to, if not completely normal, color
vision. A woman could possibly show signs of BCM if she inherits a
defective X that is unable to adequately "protect" her from the
deficiency of cone pigment caused by the abnormal genes on her other X
chromosome.
A male, on the other hand, has only one X chromosome so any
defect on that chromosome will be phenotypicaly expressed since he
lacks a second X chromosome to mask the faulty genes expression. As a
result, if a male has the BCM defect on his X Chromosome, no red or
green pigment is formed and he will be affected by BCM.
Inheritance
A woman who is a carrier of BCM, which means that she has a
defective X chromosome but dose not display phenotypic symptoms, has a
50% chance of producing a gamete with an abnormal X chromosome,
according to the Law of Random Alignment. Therefore, when the mother
is a carrier of BCM and the father is unaffected, there is a 50% chance
that any pregnancy, which results in a daughter, will produce a
carrier. For any pregnancy that results in a son, there is a 50%
chance that the child will have BCM. Likewise, there is a %)% chance
of her birthing an unaffected offspring.
If a male affected with BCM has children with a normal female,
then all of the children will receive a normal maternal X chromosome.
All female offspring will receive the fathers X-chromosome coding for
BCM and thus will be carriers. All males will receive an unaffected Y
chromosome and a normal maternal X chromosome and thus be completely
unaffected.
Causes of BCM
Deletions, rearrangements, and point mutations in the red and
green pigment genes have been implicated in causing BCM. One study
reported to the OMIM web page stated that nine out of ten families
studied showed deletions in the gene encoding the red-sensitive photo
pigment and/or in the region upstream of the red pigment gene which
contains that locus control region and other regulatory sequences. In
the same nine families the red pigment gene showed a range of deletions
from the loss of a single exon (the DNA base sequence of a gene that
encode and amino acid) to loss of the complete red pigment-producing
gene. In the other family, there was a loss of the complete green
producing pigment gene. Another study reported that the alterations to
the chromosome fell into two classes. One class arose from the wild
type by a two-step pathway consisting of unequal homologous
recombination and point mutation. The second class arose by
nonhomologuous deletion of genomic DNA adjacent to the red and green
pigment gene cluster. Apparently the research supports the existence
of multiple one and two-step mutational pathways to BCM. In a more
recent study it was reported that out of 24 subjects there where eight
genotypes found that would be predicted to eliminate the function of
the red green pigment. Thus, BCM could be caused by the absence of a
gene producing red or green cone cell pigment, or the deletion of an
exon on one of those genes, or by the damaging of a locus region that
controls the production of those pigment.
Options
Regional localization of the locus for BCM has the potential to
improve carrier detection and to provide antenatal (early cellular
detection_ diagnosis in families at risk for the disease. If a women
suspects that she may be a carrier of BCM because a sibling, father, or
grandfather has the disorder, she can contact a genetics counselor who
can determine through DNA analysis of a blood sample if she is a
carrier. I a woman happens to be a carrier pre-natal testing such as
CAVS or amniocentesis can accurately determine if the child will be
affected by
BCM. Despite the rarity of BCM and Achromatopsia and Internet based
network has been formed by a woman whom is a complete Achromat (no
functioning cone cells) to allow those people affected to correspond
with one another. The network is also open to health care provider and
scientist interested in learning more about these types of retinal
disorders. For more information visit www.acromatopsia.org
References
1. Online Mendeline Inheritance in Man, OMIM. Johns Hopkins
University, Baltimore, MD. MIM Number (303700): (10/5/98):.
World Wide Web URL: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/omim/.
2. Achromatiopsia Network, 200. World Wide Web URL:
http://www.achromat.org/
3. National Organization for Rare Disorders NORD), 2000. World
Wide Web URL: http://www.rarediseases.org/.
Return to the Project Table of Contents
Copyright © 2001, Dr. John M. Morgan, All rights reserved -
This page last edited March 12, 2001
If you have any feedback for the author, E-mail me