Amy Wallace 12-5-99 Psychology 472 Final Paper "And always, when will it happen again? Which of my feelings are real? Which of the me's is me? The wild, impulsive, chaotic, energetic, and crazy one? Or the shy, withdrawn, desperate, suicidal, doomed, and tired one? Probably a bit of both, hopefully much that is neither." (1) The symptoms of what is now labeled bipolar disorder have been recorded in history up to 2,000 years ago. A man named Kraepelin first called it manic depressive disorder in 1913. It is the most fatal affective disorder: approximately 15-20% of people afflicted with bipolar disorder commit suicide. Although 1.2 million Americans are diagnosed with it every year, it remains today the most unrecognized, untreated of all psychiatric disorders. Bipolar disorder is characterized by periods of depression alternating with manic episodes. Patients describe depressions as feeling slow, hopeless, and unable to experience any type of pleasure. One patient says in describing depression (in reference to her brain,) "the wretched convoluted thing works only well enough to torment me with a dreary litany of my inadequacies and shortcomings of character, and to haunt me with the total, the desperate hopelessness of it all." (1) Manic periods are described as feeling hyper, fast and energetic. Manic states are divided into two categories: "mania", which refers to drastic changes and a heightening in mood, speech, energy, and cognitive and physical activity. The person sleeps less (or not at all), becomes irritable, irrational, impulsive, and possibly paranoid and delusional. A patient describing a past, particularly intense manic episode writes, "I was a messiah. I was going to the Orient to bring an end to the evil of Communism and bring the religions of the Orient into line with Christianity. I was saying, 'All right, all the whites over here, all the blacks over there. We're going to have us a Chinese fire drill!' So in comes the security and takes me into the quiet room. And down there I was spitting on a light bulb, thinking if I watched the saliva burn, the different colors and shapes, I could find the key to the cure for cancer." (1) "Hypomania" is a diluted form of mania, characterized mainly by extra energy, and a sense of hope and well being. Some people diagnosed with bipolar disorder enjoy the periods of hypomania, even to the point of discontinuing medication to restore the highs. A 19 year old was informed of his diagnosis during such a period and replied, "If I'm ill, this is the most wonderful illness I've ever had." (1) Bipolar disorder has been categorized into two groups: bipolar I and bipolar II. Bipolar I is the more severe form, depression is very intense (described by philosophers as melancholia for centuries), and the individual may become psychotic in the manic phase. Delusions of grandeur and auditory hallucinations may occur. Bipolar II is marked by chronic depression intermixed with hypomanic episodes, never reaching the terrifying manic stage. However, anxiety and obsessive compulsive tendencies are sometimes effects of the hypomanic state. The transitional period between the two extremes is referred to as "mixed mania" or dysphoric mania, including feelings of excitement, agitation, and depression. According to a recent survey, only an estimated 27% of bipolar individuals are treated, the lowest of all psychiatric disorders. Both types are theorized to be genetic: usually approximately 20% of patient's relatives have some affective disorder. The top four most common disorders diagnosed in relatives are: bipolar I and II, unipolar depression, schizoaffective disorder, and suicidal tendencies. An exact gene that causes bipolar disorder has not been discovered. Some researchers believe a contribution to developing bipolarity is exposure to intimate relatives that exhibit chaotic behaviors. Alcohol and drug abuse has also been continuously prominent in many families of bipolar people, also with individual patients. Studies estimate 31.5% of bipolar I and 20.8% of bipolar II patients are addicted to alcohol. One theory attempting to explain why alcoholism is so prevalent in people with bipolar disorder is a genetic explanation. The "assortive mating" hypothesis states that bipolar patients are more likely to marry people with alcoholism. Another line of thinking is that alcohol consumption may be a result of manic behavior, possibly as an attempt at self- medication,(which is actually counter productive,) or simply the product of "an expansive lifestyle" seen in many manic patients. (4) More women than men are diagnosed with this disorder, and the average age of onset is late adolescence to young adulthood. Early treatment is considered best and most effective, for the obvious reason that this is a painful, harmful illness, but also due to the "kindling" hypothesis. This theory proposes that the more an individual has manic and depressed episodes, the more their neurophysiology becomes accustom to these states. Therefore, they are more likely to reoccur. Bipolar disorder is a reality, affecting millions of lives each year. Much is known about the behavioral, emotional, and cognitive effects. However, the question plaguing many remains: what exactly is occurring physiologically in bipolar disorder? The answer is evasive. Biochemical, anatomical and neurological theories attempt to explain the organic basis for such an illness. None are completely conclusive, but following are some of the intriguing and more accepted hypothesis. Some researches believe that a lack of serotonin in the limbic system causes hypersensitivity in neurons. This would possibly lead to "exaggerated behavioral response" in the individual. An electrolyte and membrane hypothesis posits that neuron membrane differences (bipolar patients had protein structural abnormalities in some studies) may be responsible for the chemical imbalance. There are a plethora of amine theories, some describing catecholoamine deficiency. Others examine changes in levels of dopamine, norepinephrine, seratonin, and acetylcholine. Phenylethylamine is the only trace amine studied extensively by psychiatry because of its similar construction to amphetamine and its dramatic emotional effects. The data is more conclusive for unipolar depressed patients than bipolar, however. It has been noted that hypothyroidism has been associated with depression and sometimes mania; poorly regulated thyroid function involves many characteristics of depression such as changes in sleeping patterns and loss of appetite. Sleeplessness, in fact, is a major precipitator of a manic episode in bipolar patients, and benzodiazepines have been proven very effective when given in addition to Lithium as an antimanic and sleep inducing agent. Anticonvulsants such as carbamazepine and ECT have been increasingly popular in treating bipolar disorder. ECT has been proven very effective with both depressive and manic episodes, in breaking a particularly, perhaps suicidal episode, and effective in treating patients who are unresponsive to other drugs. It is also effective in treating mixed mania, and safe for pregnant women. (2) Brain tumors and lesions provide us with interesting data. In a study done with 85 people having a tumor in their frontal lobe, 13 were depressed and 5 were manic or hypomanic. Another study with 110 individuals with tumors in their temporal lobes revealed 21 were depressed and 6 were hypomanic. Dichotic listening studies show (inconclusively) impaired functioning in the right hemisphere of the brain. One study on handidness indicated people with bipolar disorder more likely than normal to be left handed. Two patients apparently switched hand preference when transitioning from depression to mania. Central blood flow (CBF) and metabolism has been studied in correlation to the disease. Two "rapid cycling" patients (meaning they switched from depressed to manic states rapidly) showed approximately 36% higher global metabolic rates on a subjective good, happy day than on a bad day. However, on average, metabolism in the frontal lobe was 40% lower than normal. This indicates lessened activity in the frontal lobe may be associated with bipolar depression. A "robust finding" due to MRI research showed that the caudate nucleus in the affective disorder group got smaller. New technological advances such as these are radically adding to knowledge about brain activity and physiology. (1) Other theories point to the importance of (predominantly natural) light and people's sensitivity to it. It is thought that bipolar patients perhaps have a very high vulnerability to external stresses. As with SAD (Seasonal Affective Disorder), depressions occur less during the summer months in bipolar patients. Bipolar patients are poorly prepared for changes in circadian rhythms such as night, day, summer, and winter. This proposes disturbances of regulatory and adaptive mechanisms. Some patients may respond positively from such simple treatment as using a light box on days when they are depressed.(2) As discussed before, the rate of bipolar patients who abuse alcohol and drugs is high. Some researches theorize that cocaine use may be directly linked to the earlier age of onset in bipolar disease. This leads to the more inclusive "cohort effect", which describes how there are more affective disorders diagnosed now than ever before, and this might be related to environmental stress. In the last four decades, alcohol consumption, tobacco, and drug use has inclined, perhaps catalyzing the onset of these illnesses. Drug use is extremely dangerous in bipolar individuals; very commonly it directly induces a manic or depressive episode. In fact, 43% of bipolar patients who abuse drugs and alcohol commit suicide. Fundamentally, we do not yet know what, exactly, causes bipolar disorder. According to popular belief, we have learned more in the last 10 years about the organization and operation of the brain than ever before. As research, testing, and innovative procedures evolve, more information is sure to be generated. Fortunately, we have found substances that greatly help bipolar patients. By far, the most popular and effective treatment is Lithium. Lithium is sodium based, and "alters monoamine metabolism…sustains nerve impulse conduction and affects the endocrine system; produces significant changes in electrolyte balance and metabolism, and it may alter intermediary metabolism." (5) Lithium works as an antimanic and antidepressant agent, and also works to decrease cycle frequency. Other drugs, such as Carbamazepine and Valproate have been gaining popularity as alternatives for Lithium for specific patient needs. It has been stated that for bipolar disorder the generally desired outcome of treatment should be "nothing in excess." Lithium, for most patients, provides a stable mindset, where their mood swings are easier to control. If Lithium is discontinued approximately 50% of people will relapse. The real problem evolves however, when Lithium ceases to perform its duty when given again. Why this happens is not understood, but now it is generally accepted that Lithium should not be discontinued (unless absolutely necessary or completely ineffective.) Approximately 1,000 tests involving Lithium's effects are done annually to better understand it, and its interaction with other drugs. Neuroleptics (antipsychotic drugs) are sometimes administered if the patient seems to be acting in a possibly dangerous way. Some doctors feel that Lithium, given in conjunction with an antidepressant, anticonvulsant, or thyroid hormone is the best form of treatment. Fundamentally, each patient is different, and should be treated accordingly. (6) Diagnosing people with bipolar disorder involves recognizing typical characteristics of the illness. The ten most prominent manifestations of the disorder are: "suicidal thoughts, insomnia, hypersexuality, grandiosity, racing thoughts, confused thinking, irritability, auditory hallucinations, drug and alcohol abuse, and poor response to standard treatment." (2) Informing the patient of their diagnosis in a supportive, compassionate way is usually conducive to patient compliance, and results in the most beneficial and effective treatment possible. This involves ensuring the individual understands that bipolar disease is a chronic disorder, and that treatments are not a cure. Both family and people in the work place are affected, sometimes acutely. Working with the family in a therapeutic setting is helpful, as is educating the person's loved ones about the disease. Alertness to early symptoms, and information about possible side effects is also necessary. Educating the patient about the importance of compliance with medicine is also crucial; people with bipolar disorder have an almost 50% noncompliance rate. Someday molecular genetic studies may allow us to detect a specific chromosomal abnormality that explains bipolar disorder. People could be treated before any symptoms of the disease manifested, and the pathophysiology of the illness could be explained. However, this may not be possible for another 30 or 40 years, and bipolar disorder may never be linked to a specific neurological disfunction. Fortunately medical science has found effective methods of treatment, and is continuing to explore new and innovative techniques that will hopefully make bipolar disorder a less ominous and enigmatic illness. Bibliograghy 1. Goodwin, Frederick K. Manic Depressive Illness New York: Oxford University Press, 1990. 2."Brain Body Connection" PBS,1997. 3. Goodnick, Paul J. Mania, Clinical and Research Perspectives. London: American Psychiatric Press, Inc.1998. 4. Goldberg, Joseph. Bipolar Disorders. London: American Psychiatric Press, Inc. 1999. 5. Zubin, Joseph. Disorders of Mood. Baltimore: The John Hopkins Press, 1969. 6. Georgotas, Anastasios. Depression and Mania. New York: Elseveir, 1998.Return to the Project Table of Contents
Copyright © 1999, Dr. John M. Morgan, All rights
reserved -
This page last edited 13 - December, 1999
If you have any feedback for the author, E-mail me